Which of below is American and which is british English when you want someone to explain themselves?

What carry out you have to say for yourself?

What have actually you acquired to say because that yourself?


*

Both are recognizable as AE, although if my parents, say, request me as a young the 2nd one, it would certainly be tough not come laugh. Because the usage of gained in such a context appears jarringly out of location (i.e., obtained is colloquial, whereas a need for one explanation from a exceptional calls for an ext formal language).
Actually the very first one may be considered old fashioned by some but it is the correct version.

You are watching: What do you have to say for yourself

In the second version the word "got" is not needed. That is superfluous.

I was brought up to never say "I"ve got" (I have actually got). If you have actually it, then you gained it. The is an extremely bad grammar.

Unfortunately, it is now being provided on the BBC. Because that example, "we"ve acquired our correspondent (............) ~ above the heat now". No! It should be "we have (or currently have) ours correspondent.....

"What have we got after that this evening?" No! It have to be "What execute we have afterwards this evening?"

One the the worst for me is the location of a programme dubbed "Have we obtained news because that you." No! It have to be "Have we news because that you" or "Do we have actually news for you".

My point is that the usage of words "got" with "have" is poor English.


share
enhance this prize
follow
answered january 12 "15 at 6:46
*

MoragMorag
34611 silver- badge44 bronze badges
2
add a comment |

her Answer


Thanks for contributing response to English Language Learners ridge Exchange!

Please be sure to answer the question. Carry out details and also share her research!

But avoid

Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.Making statements based on opinion; ago them up with references or an individual experience.

To learn more, view our tips on writing great answers.

See more: Renaissance European Day Spa Fayetteville Nc, Renaissance European Day Spa: Home


Draft saved
Draft discarded

Sign increase or log in


sign up making use of Google
authorize up using Facebook
sign up utilizing Email and Password
submit

Post together a guest


surname
email Required, yet never shown


Post together a guest


name
email

Required, but never shown


write-up Your price Discard

By clicking “Post her Answer”, girlfriend agree come our terms of service, privacy policy and also cookie policy


Not the prize you're spring for? Browse other questions tagged american-english british-english or questioning your own question.


Featured ~ above Meta
Linked
1
Is it correct to to speak "I don't have actually time"
related
5
"They have actually *both* acquired ..." or "They *both* have gained ..."
0
The usage of have vs. Have acquired in the past
2
have obtained phrase because that Americans
1
Have and have got in BrE
2
Have gained in BrE
1
obtained to have actually noticed
1
I have just acquired vs. Ns just acquired
warm Network concerns an ext hot inquiries

inquiry feed
i ordered it to RSS
concern feed To i ordered it to this RSS feed, copy and also paste this URL right into your RSS reader.


*

English Language learners
firm
stack Exchange Network
site style / logo design © 2021 ridge Exchange Inc; user contributions license is granted under cc by-sa. Rev2021.9.23.40291


English Language Learners stack Exchange works finest with JavaScript permitted
*

your privacy

By click “Accept all cookies”, friend agree ridge Exchange have the right to store cookie on your an equipment and disclose information in accordance with our Cookie Policy.