Dear Quote Investigator: The creator of the following insightful saying was noted as unknown:

Don’t exercise until you gain it right. Practice until girlfriend can’t get it wrong.

You are watching: Practice until you can t get it wrong

While looking for background details I came across this interesting variation:

Amateurs exercise till they get it right; professionals practice till they can’t get it wrong.

Could you find out much more about this modern-day dictum?

Quote Investigator: since this adage can be to express in countless ways that is challenging to trace. The earliest evidence located by QI was in the domain of education in 1902. A school superintendent named George W. Loomis whose speak was videotaped in the “Michigan school Moderator” discussed the best method to teach students come spell properly and also employed a precursor the the modern-day proverb. Boldface has actually been added to some excerpts below: 1

It need to be admitted that spelling is not taught successfully; indeed, the challenge lies in the fact that that is seldom taught at all. Assignment lessons are assigned, studied, recited, however not taught. Lot of the time invested in hearing kids recite—guess till they get it right—should be invested in a definite to teach process, until they can not gain it wrong.

In 1922 the distinctive second fifty percent of the expression was supplied in one educational publication titled “Swimming and Diving”: 2

This coordination of arms and legs is maybe the most an overwhelming as well together the most crucial thing about the chest stroke. ~ each aspect has to be mastered separately, practice the combination on floor until friend cannot get it wrong.

In 1944 a full version the the adage showed up in the volume “Psychology for Musicians” by Percy C. Buck who was an organist and a influential Professor that Music in ~ the college of London. This popular book was reprinted numerous times in the succeeding decades. Buck did not take credit for the speak which to be presented together an anonymous definition: 3 4

What is the actual difference between a professional and also an amateur? Does no your mind immediately turn to the shallow explanation of money-payments? Two interpretations have to be made which may help you to think deeper 보다 that:

“An amateur have the right to be solve with discovering a fact; a skilled must recognize the reason why.”

“An amateur practises until he can do a thing right, a experienced until that can’t execute it wrong.”

Here are added selected citations in chronological order.

In 1963 the speak was provided again in the music domain in a newspaper in Iowa. One orchestra conductor called Dr. Francis Mayer of St. Thomas University, Minneapolis speak the expression: 5

Dr. Mayer called the team that the difference between an amateur and also a expert is that “an amateur methods until he have the right to do everything right and a experienced practices till he can’t perform anything wrong.”

In in march 1971 an circumstances of the expression was printed in a newspaper short article by the journalist Peter Crossley around a Canadian music festival: 6

“An amateur techniques until he gets it right; a professional practices till he can’t obtain it wrong” stated adjudicator Kenneth valve Barthold in adjudicating class 245 — Pianoforte Solo — progressed — final at the Planetarium Auditorium in the Friday evening session the the Manitoba Music competition Festival.

In November 1971 Peter Crossley consisted of the speak in another article he wrote. The domain of application was switched from music come theater, and also the word “practices” was changed with “rehearses”: 7

It is said in theatre that an amateur rehearses till he it s okay it right yet a expert rehearses until he can’t acquire it wrong.

In 1988 a partial instance of the adage was had in the novel “A Postcard from Rome” by David Helwig: 8

Edith had constantly obeyed a piece of advice that confidence had offered her early on on: if you room a professional, you perform not practise until you can acquire it right, friend practise till you cannot gain it wrong.

Top quotation experienced Nigel Rees included an circumstances of the adage in the April 1994 worry of his ‘Quote … Unquote’ Newsletter. The words to be attributed to the music professor Harold Craxton: 9 10

‘Amateurs exercise until castle can acquire it right; specialists practice till they can’t gain it wrong’ (quoted by Harold Craxton, one-time professor at the imperial Academy of Music).

In 1996 Robert Page, a Professor of Music and also Director that Choral researches at Carnegie Mellon University, work the speak which the ascribed to the Oscar-winning actress Julie Andrews: 11

“Julie Andrews as soon as said an amateur rehearses till he it s okay it right,” web page said. “A professional rehearses till he can’t acquire it wrong.”

The sports of the speak without the words “amateur” and “professional” appears to have actually been created relatively recently. Below is an instance used by a veterinarian in a vermouth newspaper in February 2013: 12

For safety and to market your pet the best care we have actually to gain it appropriate every time. To do that, we exercise together. We don’t exercise until we get it right, we practice until us can’t gain it wrong.

See more: Am I In The Friend Zone ? 7 Signs You'Re Stuck In The Stupid Friend Zone

In conclusion, this saying v the native “amateur” and “professional” was in circulation through 1944, and also its originator was anonymous. It has been an especially popular in the music domain.

(Great thanks to optimal lexicographical researcher Barry Popik who obtained important citations if tracing this expression. Many thanks to Jonathan Lighter and also other ADS perform participants whose electronic messages presented QI come this expression. Special thanks to Nigel Rees who wonderful newsletter discussed this saying. Good thanks to Jason DeVillains